comparison chart of metal roof vs standard shingles

Metal Roof Vs. Shingles (Pros & Cons)

When it comes time to replace your roof, you have a big decision to make. Should you go with standard asphalt shingles? Or something more premium, like metal?

As metal roofs climb the ladder of popularity among homeowners, they are often compared against shingled roofs. While they both have their share of pros and cons, how do you know which one is the best? We’re here to help you figure that out.

This guide will help you make an educated decision on which is right for you: a metal roof or asphalt shingles?

What Is Metal Roofing?

Metal roofing has come a long way from being those loud, ugly tin roofs used for barns and lean-tos. It has morphed into one of the go-to options for modern homeowners.

Types of metal roofing include:

  • Steel: The most common metal roofing. It’s affordable and durable but can rust over time.
  • Aluminum: A lightweight metal that doesn’t rust. It’s a good choice for homes in coastal areas or anywhere with high humidity.
  • Copper: An expensive metal that develops a beautiful patina over time. You’ll see it often in historic homes.
  • Zinc: A metal that doesn’t corrode and is environmentally friendly.
  • Tin: A metal once often used in roofing but has fallen out of popularity.

The type of metal used can vary, and each has its benefits vs. downfalls, but there are also different styles of metal roofing that can change the way the roof performs overall. Homeowners can install corrugated panels, standing seams, and even metal shingles.

Metal roofs now come in various colors, styles, and patterns that can mimic the look of just about any kind of roofing material out there. So while the performance of metal has always been quite enticing, now homeowners have the added benefit of its beautiful curb appeal as well.

metal roof vs. shingles

The Benefits of a Metal Roof

We’ve touched on a few of the benefits of metal roofing, but the list goes on and on. Benefits of a metal roof include:

Strength and Durability

Metal roofs are solid and durable. They can withstand wind, rain, hail, ice, and more. Unlike many shingles, metal roofs will withstand wind gusts up to 140 mph and won’t corrode or crack.

Low Maintenance

Roof maintenance is vital to ensuring your roof lasts as long as possible, so finding a low-maintenance roofing system is something many homeowners look for. Metal roofs shed water and debris super well and can be cleaned easily with a hose or soft wash, making them very low maintenance.

Gorgeous Curb Appeal

Metal roofs come in a variety of colors, styles, and patterns that can accent the rest of your home’s exterior super well. A new metal roof can make your home look good as new with pristine colors and styles that go well with most styles of homes.

Fire and Insect Resistance

Metal roofs are Class A rated against fire, the highest fire-resistance rating for roofing. It means it can withstand severe exposure to fire from outside. It is also highly resistant to insects and rodents.

Environmentally Friendly

Metal roofs are made of recycled materials and can be 100% recyclable at the end of their lifespan. They also reflect sunlight and heat, which helps keep homes cooler in the summer months.

Long-Lasting

A metal roof can last anywhere from 40 to 70 years and sometimes even longer when installed and maintained well. This makes metal roofs a significant long-term investment for your home.

Replicate More Premium Options

While metal roofs are a premium roofing system, metal roofing options can replicate the look of more premium materials like slate and wood shake.

house with GAF slateline metal shingles
Image from: https://www.gaf.com/en-us/roofing-products/residential-roofing-products/shingles/designer-shingles/value-collection/slateline

 

What Is a Shingled Roof?

On the other hand, a shingled roof can be one of many different materials, including metal. But a standard asphalt shingle roof is the most commonly used residential roofing type in America. Shingles are installed layer by layer and include roofing tar and granules that act as a solid first layer of protection for your home.

Shingles can be big, small, come in sheets of 3 or even single shingles. The most common type is the asphalt shingle, which we will focus on in this blog post.

Asphalt shingles are made of fiberglass saturated with asphalt and then covered in granules. They come in various colors and styles to choose from to match your home.

Shingles are less expensive than metal roofing, which is one of their main benefits. They are also much easier and cheaper to install, making them a popular choice for many homeowners.

The Benefits of Asphalt Shingles

There are many reasons why asphalt shingles remain the #1 choice of homeowners. The benefits include:

Affordable

One of the biggest draws to asphalt shingles is their affordability. They are one of the most inexpensive roofing materials on the market, making them an excellent option for budget-conscious homeowners.

Easy to Install

Asphalt shingles are much easier to install than metal roofing. They can be installed by a small team and only take about a day for an average-sized roof. Because of the quick turnaround time, the savings on labor for an asphalt shingle roof is one of the reasons why they are so affordable.

Low Maintenance

Shingled roofs are relatively hands-off when it comes to maintaining them. Homeowners should get their roof soft-washed at least every few years, keep it free of debris, clean out the gutters, and make swift repairs. Keeping a close eye on it and doing minor maintenance can ensure it lasts for 25+ years.

Aesthetically Pleasing

Shingled roofs go with nearly any style and architecture of homes. They are highly versatile but always aesthetically pleasing.

Countless Color and Style Options

The options are endless for homeowners to be able to match their shingles to their home’s siding or exterior.

close up of metal roof shingles

Metal Roof Vs. Shingles (Pros and Cons)

Comparing the two side by side can help you determine the best option for you. While they vary greatly, it’s crucial to weigh the options such as price, ease of installation, and style, which could sway a homeowner’s purchase decision.

✅  An asphalt shingle roof costs an average of $8,000.

🚫 A metal roof costs an average of $10,700.

✅  Metal roofs last from 40-70 years.

🚫 Asphalt shingle roofs last an average of 25 years.

✅  Metal roofs are made from recycled materials and can be 100% recyclable.

🚫 Shingles are not recyclable and end up in landfills.

✅  When installed correctly, metal roofs can withstand high winds up to 140 mph.

🚫 Shingle roofs can only withstand wind gusts up to 60 mph.

✅  Asphalt shingles are very easy to install.

🚫 Depending on the style, metal roofs may take longer and require more expert contractors to properly install.

Tips for Choosing the Right Material for Your Home

There are many things that homeowners must consider before choosing metal roof vs. shingles for their home. But one of the best ways to determine what you should go with is to find a trustworthy contractor to help.

Durashield is highly experienced in both shingle and metal roofs, and we may be biased, but our customized metal roofing solutions can help boost curb appeal and up the value of your home. If you’re interested in seeing what type of metal roofing we can install for you, reach out to us!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to Top